Long Island man wants his kidney back from ex.

Status
Not open for further replies.
goldfish

goldfish

New Member
Feb 8, 2006
2,652
2,687
0
Huntington
www.flowers-insolita.com
State / Prov
NY
A Long Island doctor donated his kidney to his wife in 2001, possibly saving her life. Now she wants divorce, so he wants his kidney back, or $1.5 million, the value he claims his kidney is worth.

Read here:

http://www.nydailynews.com/ny_local...long_island_doctor_richard_batista_to_es.html

This is the biggest news in Long Island right now. We Long Islanders desperately needed some news that makes us all feel good.
 
That's a hefty price to put on the mother of the children. Sure would like to hear her side.

V
 
Wonder if my first husband will give me back "my youth" that he stole from me.
.......only kidding.
I would say that since the said Kidney was in his body during the marriage and given during the marriage, that makes it joint property.
Had the said Kidney been donated prior to their union, it is the opinion of this court he would then be entitled to have it back.
In addition I submit documentation received by the hospital that he signed on the dotted line of his own free will, accepting all complications and conditions regarding his donation to the recipient.
It is estimated at the time of the donation the said wife, cooked, cleaned, shopped, scheduled appointments, maintained the household, kept his golf membership up to date, paid the insurance in his Mercedes and had his children.
Therefore, deducting an estimated hourly rate for all duties performed and deducting the depreciation on the said "used" donated Kidney. The doctor now owes said wife 2.3 million dollars.
I rest my case.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Beth, shannonlovesflowers, Chezbloom and 7 others
Sadly I can't dot you in this forum... I'll find another way. :)

V
 
vghstaffer said:
Wonder if my first husband will give me back "my youth" that he stole from me.
.......only kidding.
I would say that since the said Kidney was in his body during the marriage and given during the marriage, that makes it joint property.
Had the said Kidney been donated prior to their union, it is the opinion of this court he would then be entitled to have it back.
In addition I submit documentation received by the hospital that he signed on the dotted line of his own free will, accepting all complications and conditions regarding his donation to the recipient.
It is estimated at the time of the donation the said wife, cooked, cleaned, shopped, scheduled appointments, maintained the household, kept his golf membership up to date, paid the insurance in his Mercedes and had his children.
Therefore, deducting an estimated hourly rate for all duties performed and deducting the depreciation on the said "used" donated Kidney. The doctor now owes said wife 2.3 million dollars.
I rest my case.
Click to expand...

That made me laugh out loud. I even heard the disgust in your voice!
Dang, that was funny!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom
Back