If I were evaluating, and the instructions asked for a boutonniere, I would deduct points in the "category interpretation" category.
Often, though, the category is much broader. Such as "flowers for a best man to wear" rather than "best man boutonniere"
As for points, I think that glued will get slightly fewer points in mechanics category, but you may make them up in creativity. Great wire-and-tape technique will always garner a lot of mechanics points since the evaluators know it takes real skill. If you glue, you are limiting the amount of points that the evaluators can give you, because you've chosen the easier mechanics route.
Many times, I have said that if I could only give ONE piece of advice to someone before AES, that advice would be:
Give the evaluators every opportunity to bestow points!
So, there you go....
For me personally, taping and wiring is easier than gluing.
I think gluing (not pan glue) takes forever.
I think I'm going to stop worrying about this. I'm going to go in, do what I do, do it to the best of my ability. And If I fail, well I guess I'll have to do it again.
I hear soooo much stuff about "they do this at AES and they do that"
The one that sticks in my mind is, They turn the arrangement upside down, if it falls apart, you don't pass. So I guess I'll make stuff that will survive the upside down test. There will be no foam showing, no tape showing, Binding will be done well, and so will the banding. I will have depth, and good lines, and all my greens will be meaningful, there will be nothing in any design that isn't necessary, and it will all be done creatively. Dirty water will be changed, and no floaters in the water, and no foliage below the water line, and the stems will look just as neat as the flowers above the rim, if you can in fact see the stems. And done within the time allotted with nothing more than what was provided to me, and I will only take the tools I'm allowed.
I heard about the woman claiming not to pass because of a "500th of a point" I call BS there!
I heard about a woman who had to take it 24 times. well, ok
I think I can do it. Hopefully, I wont fall apart.. I'll think of my buddy BJ when I'm telling myself not to fall apart and how he calmed me down at the Colorado cup. I'm sure he's not fully aware of how much his kind words to me were really words of encouragement.
Then I will focus on my task at hand, try not to shake, and just do what I do.
What more can I do?
So, I'm gonna say this again, and I hope I can stick to it... I'm gonna stop worrying about this. I have to.
Really, this is my own personal pep talk to myself. Just kinda got typed out...
Thank you and good night!