fairfield said:Please tell me that you are not going to fall victim to gossip. Or do you believe everything an anonymous poster says? Why don't you call FSN and get the scoop for yourself? Ask them for their opinion on OG activities and whether or not they support or foster those activities.
I don't think I'm falling victim to any gossip. The original question was about opinions concerning FSN. The question has to be that if you invest money in ANY directory, what kind of return can you expect. Flowersmith is happy, but they have 2 sites and also are located very close to PIttsburgh. Is it this closeness to a major market that gets them a good response in FSN? I don't have the answer. Connie in Piedmont is the only florist IN Piedmont in the FSN listings, but 6 others are also listed as also serves. Does anyone have some facts that confirm whys she has had less than favorable results with FSN or is it because she doesn't have a website and some of the also serves do? I don't have an answer for that either. Eric stated he is less than thrilled at his results in Tustin, Ca and there are 14 florists listed for that city. Does the number of florists listed for each town downgrade any results because FSN search is not done by zip code. I suspect that it does, but I don't have any facts to back that up. Cindi in Houston seems to be very happy with her results, but again we are talking about a major market. In the FSN search on Houston, there are 43 florists listed but only 18 actually located in Houston. Is it a fact that she has a better website or the fact that there are only 14 florists listed in houston that give her a better than average result. I don't have an answer for that either. It doesn't seem to matter whether you have a website or not because there are some florists in Houston that have 2. From all appearances, it seems that the larger the local market and the fewer the florists listed, the greater the advantage for those florists.
fairfied said:Wesley Berry does operate a real florist shop last I knew. Maybe I am wrong. As for Palatine, Il, I didn't see anything alarming. Maybe you could post the suspect shop.
Many of the OG's today ARE FLORISTS! Ask any florist in Michigan and they will advise you the Wesley Berry is an OG. It is not a rumor. Yes, 99% of all people who list on a directory on doing so to gain incoming orders. It also is not to any advantage to an OG, who is a WS member, to transmit orders through to florists on a directory and only get 20% and still have to pay $3.99 for transmission. No advantage unless there is no florist in an area within the WS that will take the OG's orders and then a directory becomes the place of last resort. That's not a slam against any directory or any F2F 20/80 sending program and that means all of them! However, NO ONE is going to be able to screen out all the OG's from their system. Many OG websites today have the real ownership very well hidden. So as more and more florists leave the WS, more and more OG's will be forced to use alternatives to send their orders. That's not a rumor - that's a pure fact.
fairfield said:If you don't like their 20/80 F2F program then you don't have to participate. It appears that some shops don't benefit from their directory listings as much as others, so maybe your shop will not benefit at all from FSN.
Opinion is one thing, rumors are another...
As I have said from the very beginning, I'm not a candidate and I'm not trying to "trash" anyones program. The point of all this is it seems to work for some and for others it doesn't. The important factor to determine, what MAKES it work for some! For example, Fairfield, I can find you when I search for a FLORIST in Eugene, or a FLOWER SHOP in Eugene or DELIVER FLOWERS in Eugene. I can find you on locateaflowershop, I can even find your website through Yahoo yellow pages and superpages, but NOT through FSN at least not in the first 2 pages of any search. No, I don't think it is a regional thing. I have to use a Yahoo browser that comes with my DSL, but so does a great many other consumers today. I have been doing searches through various regions of the country and run into the same problem. The whole idea of directories is to make it easy for the consumer to find florists, but it doesn't seem to that be easy. Shouldn't florists have some expectation or guideline that tells them before you invest your money, you can expect some amount of return? How about a limit as to how many florists can be listed as also served for anyone town? How about if you already have 2 or more florists listed and have B & M for the same town, no also serves are necessary? The larger the town, the more florists that can be listed. If the directory doesn't charge for extra listing, no one really benefits, do they?