Is less choices better?

Status
Not open for further replies.

master J

Well-Known Member
Jan 8, 2005
2,434
2,675
113
53
Havertown - Philadelphia
www.belvedereflowers.com
State / Prov
pa
Ok, after viewing Oberer's website this morning , I ask myself the question, is less choices better, I find his web site to be very easy and simple choices, not too many categories or occasions(no anniversary, no get well soon, etc etc)), not a lot of text all over the page, its just clean, classy and simple! I get depressed every time I view his site, the pictures are just spectacular, and some of his ideas and prices are also great! (samplers, roses in the raw, etc).
I find it much more easier on the eyes, then like say a beneva style website or even my own tf site.

Do you think shoppers would rather have a limited selection to choose from or pages and pages of choices and occasions?

In case a few of you havn't seen oberers web site, I wanted to post links just for comparison to go on...

http://www.oberers.com/

http://www.beneva.com/

both are excellent websites, just totally different approachs, so just wanted to know what you think the internet buyers would rather shop on?
 
Boy what coincidence.

I get the Whizbang tip of the week and here it is........... Hot off the email this am

Everyone can agree that having a choice is good. A choice
about where to live, what to eat, which car to drive, what to
wear, who you hang out with, when to go to bed...

The interesting thing is that social science research has shown
that TOO MUCH CHOICE can actually be a BAD thing!

It turns out that when people choose between many options
they end up being less happy with their decision than are
people who choose between far fewer options. That’s right –
LESS happy - even when having lots of options gets them a
better outcome!

Why?

I suppose you could call it the “grass is always greener”
phenomenon. Too many choices lead to regret, remorse, and
what-if thinking.

“What if the other widget would have been softer...”
“Maybe the green one would have matched my eyes...”
“Should I have gone with the more powerful version?”

It’s the uncertainty that leads to dissatisfaction. And you don’t
want customers dissatisfied with their purchase from YOUR
store!

To top it off, when people are forced to choose from too many
options they most often choose NOTHING. And that’s a very
bad thing for your sales statistics!

Here’s what all this means for you...

You should limit your customers’ choices of products or
services. In fact, they want you to.

Your customers are counting on YOU to be the expert, the
arbiter of good taste, the guru of good sense. They want YOU
to be the one to look at all the available options, pick the best
assortment, and offer only those options.

How many choices are too many? It depends. Sometimes
only ONE choice is the right number.

At the Mackinaw Kite Co. we sold more 50# kite line on a spool
than any other item in the store. Makes sense – you can’t fly a
kite without line and all our best selling kites used 50# line. But
we didn’t offer a wide variety of 50# line; we offered ONE. The
one we thought was the best combination of price and
performance.

Can you imagine if we sold the kite and then tried to make the
customer choose from between ten, or even two, different
kinds of line?

Of course, offering only one choice is the exception, not the
rule. More often than not you’ll be giving your customers many
options to choose from. When you are deciding how many
choices to offer, ask yourself the following questions:

>> Can I clearly distinguish between differences in
performance, style, function, or value in all the items or
services I am offering? Or is there a lot of duplication between
them?

>> Do my sales statistics prove that I need a large variety
choices (my customers are buying lots of all the options that I
offer) or do they tell me that I need to trim my assortment (they
buy a lot of one or two items in an assortment but a very few of
the others).

>> Can I offer a bundled “everything” option so that your
customers don’t have to decide which separate components to
choose?

>> How many sales would I REALLY lose if I offered fewer
options? Would my customers simply choose something that I
AM offering?

>> How much easier would it make the customers’ buying
decision if I trimmed my assortment? How often does the
variety of options keep my customer from buying TODAY?

Like the famous modern architect Mies van der Rohe, adopt
the saying “Less Is More” as your guide and you won’t often go
wrong. Because more is often less.

TIP******TIP***** TIP***** TIP***** TIP***** TIP***** TIP

If you like this Tip, you’ll love the first 260! Get ‘em all at
www.whizbangtips.com

Bob and Susan Negen

WhizBang! Training

PASS IT ON!
------------------
Know someone that might enjoy getting our "WhizBang! Tip of the Week"? Feel free to forward this message to your colleagues and encourage them to sign up for the "WhizBang! Tip of the Week". As we all improve, we all grow!

To sign up for the "WhizBang! Tip of the Week", click on this link.

http://www.whizbangemail.com/cgi-bin/mojo.cgi?f=s&l=WhizBang!_Tip_of_the_Week.

Or send us an e-mail at [email protected] and write "sign me up" in the subject line.
 
Last van I bought I bought Honda because Toyota had too many varieties of theirs. I'm sure the vans are equal in quality etc. In 2 1/2 weeks (when I can walk again) I am going to do the same thing and I do believe the same is true and Honda will get my $ again.

look at justflowers and you'll see overwhelming choices, or - kcflorist used to lay claim to being "the biggest on the web", something like 1700 choices. (back when he could still use wire service images) Neither floats my boat.

I think all you need are the standard categories and about 30 choices in each.
 
Great site

Ok, after viewing Oberer's website this morning , I ask myself the question, is less choices better, I find his web site to be very easy and simple choices, not too many categories or occasions(no anniversary, no get well soon, etc etc)), not a lot of text all over the page, its just clean, classy and simple! I get depressed every time I view his site, the pictures are just spectacular, and some of his ideas and prices are also great! (samplers, roses in the raw, etc).
I find it much more easier on the eyes, then like say a beneva style website or even my own tf site.

Do you think shoppers would rather have a limited selection to choose from or pages and pages of choices and occasions?

In case a few of you havn't seen oberers web site, I wanted to post links just for comparison to go on...

http://www.oberers.com/

http://www.beneva.com/

both are excellent websites, just totally different approachs, so just wanted to know what you think the internet buyers would rather shop on?
I agree that this is a great site and I am in the same situation as you with Teleflora web site. I think with too much info out there you just confuse the customer. staff is confused too, TMI leads to to much searching for the pricing, and designs. Ironically, searching several months ago for an online site like this one led me to click on Oberer's website. I was very impressed by his site and after being sidetracked for a while I searched out this site again, orginally because of that great website, and then joined because of the great community/posting here.
 
The whizbang report is correct - too many choices lead to dilution and frustration. Having a few stand-out pieces is more impactful than a large selection of averageness. Plus, there is always room for customization :)

Ryan
 
Thanks for the kind remarks about my website.

The book Meaningful Marketing by Doug Hall pretty much agrees with Whizbang, that you can actually increase sales by cutting choices.

But the truth is I had other reasons for limiting choices.

First, from the beginning I was determined to have only unique product and images on my site. Developing products, photographing and putting them online takes time.

The other big reason I wanted to not provide too many choices was for designing production and inventory control. With limited choices I can gauge what is going to sell and produce ahead of time in quantities. For example, I know I'll sell 16-20 Strawberrys and Cream arrangements a week. I can stock that rose and make those arrangements with confidence they'll sell. If there were thousands of options one could never predict what will sell and production would be greatly hampered and inventory management would be much more difficult.

In conclusion, I'm happy with the choices I've made. I'm sure the website is one of the top preforming sites in the country for an independent traditional florist , and I've done this while spending zero dollars on online marketing. Art at Beneva can't say that.


RC
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
Definite food for thought, as we're collecting ideas for re-working our TF site as well.

Thanks!
tracy
 
This is a great thread! I'm going to look at our website in a completly different way today.

BTW, I look at Oberer's site at least weekly, maybe more. To me, it's like taking a tonic, inspiring and certainly worthy of ooohs and aaahs, with some how-can-he-do-thats thrown in.
 
I know that I for one can say that too many choices overwhelms me. I went into buy wallpaper to redo a room 15 years ago and was completely overwhelmed with the options. I ended up buying none of them because I wanted to make sure I was making the "right choice". Never did buy any wallpaper.

Wanda
 
I know that I for one can say that too many choices overwhelms me. I went into buy wallpaper to redo a room 15 years ago and was completely overwhelmed with the options. I ended up buying none of them because I wanted to make sure I was making the "right choice". Never did buy any wallpaper.

Wanda


Restaurants with 40 pages of choices.... ARGHHHHHHHHH drives me nuts and I leave.

V
 
V - You are so right!

We see those types of places disappearing here - especially 'coffee shop' type chains like Carrows, CoCo's, Spires. All had large menus but the food was often bland and pre-fabbed/nuked-to-order.

What's succeeding at the chain level here are niche places like Panera and Pick Up Stix (PF Chang's to-go) that have limited menus and make everything fresh, often in open kitchens.

The business for smaller, unique local restaurants also appears to be healthy. They have smallish signature menus and do what they do well - consistently.

Now when I see a large menu (especially if it's mixed cuisine styles) I get the feeling I'm going to be served an item that could have been picked up at Sam's or CostCo.
 
I know that I for one can say that too many choices overwhelms me. I went into buy wallpaper to redo a room 15 years ago and was completely overwhelmed with the options. I ended up buying none of them because I wanted to make sure I was making the "right choice". Never did buy any wallpaper.

Wanda


Sounds like me and window treatments. My upstairs has window treatments, every room. But downstairs has only mini blinds and wood blinds. I have wanted valances and tie back sheers for 3 years now, but get totally overwhelmed and end up doing nothing. SO frustrating.

Beth :~/
 
less is more!

I am in the process of having a custom shopping card made - because I couldn't find anything that suited my style. I want to avoid the FTD mass market look - and do something very individual and artistic. I also don't want to stock a bunch of inventory I don't like to work with - my site is really going to be centered around designers choice, and I am starting with only 25 images.

We will see if it works! I am likely 30 days from opening up my virtual shop.
 
BBJ and I....

have continually maintained, that a simple site, with limited choice "corruption" is the way to go, and HAS indeed proven itself to be the right choice!!
There IS NO "right" amount of choices, however, most shoppers want "front page" choices, and DON'T want to be searching throughout your entire site!!
Victoria hit it bang on......too many choices...NOT for me!!
 
Oberer's site is . . . .

wonderful and they obviously are VERY progressive in their marketing strategies and looking to utilize every type of profit center available to them.
I admire that.

But, RC, how do you get florists to take an order for $6.99? You must be a very smooth talker.:rolleyes:
 
RC
your website is inspiring. I have a question as to pricing, how can you afford the prices on your website.... what is your secret?

Margaret
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
wonderful and they obviously are VERY progressive in their marketing strategies and looking to utilize every type of profit center available to them.
I admire that.

But, RC, how do you get florists to take an order for $6.99? You must be a very smooth talker.:rolleyes:


Thanks,

I don't think I've ever been called a smooth talker.

That $6.99 bud vase gets wired out for $29.50.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.